how to solve
Posted by
Denis 1 Apr 2008 16:48
is it possible to solve this problem with "smart" backtracking algo using a lot of restrictions ?
Re: how to solve
As I know YES.
But there easy and beautiful math solution.
Re: how to solve
Posted by
Denis 2 Apr 2008 17:31
give me a hint how to solve it without using backtracking algorithm
thank you
Re: how to solve
ur e-mail ...
Re: how to solve
Posted by
Denis 2 Apr 2008 18:27
wetdrag@gmail.com
Re: how to solve
Please send it to me too.
eros_89@yandex.ru
Re: how to solve
About math solution.. I am trying to it by the following way:
Assume a connection between stops A and B. Then connection from B to A exists too. Then, to satisfy the problem's conditions, we have to introduce (2*n-1)*n connections (ordered in such a way that each tram route has 2*n-1 connections). All the connections are distinct.
Next, each tram stop has exactly 2*n-1 connections to other distinct stops. It is always odd integer, so every tram stop must appear exactly once at the beginning of single route, and next time it must appear (2*n-2)/2=n-1 times in the middle of other routes. It is true for all the routes.
So first we should build the following answer matrix if we consider n = 3:
1 x x x x 4
2 x x x x 5
3 x x x x 6
Then I am trying to place other elements to the matrix according to some placement rules from the thoughts above, but I am still unable to come up with a good solution.
Could someone point out, am I going correct in my math thoughts or such approach leads to naive backtracking solution? Thanks!
Sorry I was so verbose :D
Re: how to solve
Posted by
Nick J 3 Apr 2008 16:47
No more math is needed. Now you can use backtracking.
Re: how to solve
I resisted the idea of writing a backtracking algo, but decided to implement it with rule of placing elements leftmost and outermost as you suggested and got AC :) Thank you.
PS. I wonder if it is possible to write a backtracking solution without any initial placements or not.
2 Chmel_Tolstiy: Could you please give me small hint about a math solution? master.wsd064 (no spam) gmail.com
Edited by author 03.04.2008 18:27
Re: how to solve
your Idea is a 2/3 of all way. just try to find a regularity between this paths. I think it's easy.
Re: how to solve
naxart[at]yandex[dot]ru
it's my email.
Re: how to solve
I've found simple maths solution, here is my solution for n=3
1 2 3 4 5 6
2 4 6 1 3 5
3 6 2 5 1 4
Edited by author 02.06.2008 05:28
Edited by author 02.06.2008 05:28
Re: how to solve
There is no need for _smart_ backtracking. I placed 1..n on the left side and n..2n on the right side. Then I launched recursion over all cells row-by-row, column-by-column, taking every edge (i;j) exactly once, and it's AC in 0.078 sec.
For n=100 there occurs only 562 returns. So, it's almost greedy algo.
The only problem was expanding that recursion into a loop 'cuz I had stack overflow with 200x100 calls.
Edited by author 25.07.2008 17:31
Re: how to solve
I want to know too.
pkkj@tom.com
Thanks.
Re: how to solve
Posted by
svr 27 Jul 2009 11:15
Only math solution acceptable
because this is structure design problem.
I spent a lot of time but was unable to find it.
Solution easy to find in internet with key words
"decomposing complete graph in hamilton paths"
Use diameters and walk left-rigth- down with respect to them.
Edited by author 14.08.2009 11:02
Re: how to solve
Posted by
svr 27 Jul 2009 14:43
no subject
Edited by author 14.08.2009 11:03
Re: how to solve
Posted by
yyll 17 Jun 2021 22:24
Continue filling the matrix from both left and right.
Keep each pair of opposite columns contain every tram stops.